France’s Presidential Candidates – Too Wealthy To Be In Touch?

I was hanging the washing on the clothes airer in front of the fire the other morning, which is how I dry the clothes in winter since neither budgetary nor planetary concerns will allow me to invest in a tumble drier. I idly wondered if Carla was doing the same thing chez les Sarkozy and quickly realised that was extremely unlikely. I also imagine it’s equally unlikely that they keep just the one room warm during winter, or buy stuff from the reduced shelf in the supermarket.

Now, don’t get me wrong. We were happy to downsize when we came here since it meant our lives became infinitely more interesting, challenging and meaningful than they had ever been. But there are an awful lot of people in this country who aren’t massively better off than we are. According to INSEE, the average monthly income in France is €2,068 (and 10% of the population are on less than €1,124). That’s an average salary of €24,816 and bear in mind that Paris will be skewing those figures upwards. I’ve also seen reports that give €19,000 as the annual average, and départments such as Creuse are a good bit lower. The net monthly income per household here is given as €1,893 which is €903 per person. Paris, département 75, in comparison is €3,374 per household, €1,769 per person. (Figs from this website.)

I don’t think many politicians, and particularly not presidential candidates, are living on those average levels of salary. So all this got me to wondering how ‘in touch’ those candidates are with real life. Are they affected by any of the austerity measures, or any of these ‘green’ or ‘anti obesity’ taxes that keep whacking up the price of fuel and food items in the shops? Do they even notice them? I think not.

From http://www.20minutes.fr/

I did a quick dig around and discovered that three out of the four front-runners for presidency are extremely wealthy people. Sarkozy is worth more than 2 million euros. He’s on a salary of €240,000, which he increased from €101,000 when he became President. You can see why people are so keen to get the job if it means you can give yourself a nice pay rise!

Marine le Pen comes from a very wealthy family. Jean-Marie le Pen is a millionaire and his daughter isn’t short of a bob or two either. I’ve come across references to her as ‘la fille riche’ of M le Pen. And François Hollande, when with Ségolene Royal, declared property worth 1.8 m euros alone.

So it seems it’s François Bayrou, the son of a farmer, who is the most connected to the people he hopes to represent because of his humble background and lack of fortune. He’s also the only one of the big four who didn’t have an élite education.

Is it time for another revolution, but without the guillotine this time around? It’s starting to look like wealthy aristocrats are at the country’s helm again. I for one don’t feel they have any real inkling of normal, everyday life in France. But my feelings are irrelevant since, as a non-French national yet tax paying resident, I can’t vote anyway!

0 Replies to “France’s Presidential Candidates – Too Wealthy To Be In Touch?”

  1. Steph, I’ve been following the goings on in other countries more than France, I’m afraid, but it’s ‘good’ to see not much is different here. In the US Congress half the representatives are millionaires. I doubt this reflects the population they are representing very accurately. In Canada, CEO salaries popped up 27% last year and the numbers were similar in the US. The gap has become a chasm. Yes, I’d say it’s time for another revolution.

    1. It’s also a bit of a case of are they politicians because they’re wealthy, or are they wealthy because they’re politicians? Whichever way round, they have no idea what most of us are up against in everyday life.
      I’d better start learning the Marseillaise!

  2. I think the same can be said of Britain too. Switzerland is- happily- a mixed bag and we have all sorts of people in our 7 person Bundesrat who are effectively the cabinet – the one from nearest to me is a farmer and certainly not wealthy (not that I agree with his politics mind you!).

    1. Switzerland sounds to have got it about right. You have to have leaders who are in touch with the people they’re leading. Otherwise it becomes very ‘them’ and ‘us’ and that’s never good.

  3. Thanks for providing the average salaries in France, etc. – you saved me from having to do some research!

    I have to admit that conspicuous consumption is noticeable in Paris in a way that it isn’t in Switzerland – not that there aren’t wealthy people/politicians there, but it’s different than in Paris. Stephane and I are left shaking our heads and wondering who are the people who can afford to pay such high prices. Now I know the answer – it’s the French politicians. Are they disconnected from the masses? Yes, most definitely!

    And don’t even get me started on what’s happening with the elections in the United States! The post that I wrote for today is about one candidate’s negative advertisement about another one because he speaks….French (gasp!).

    1. If you read Gerry’s comment, you’ll see he pointed out that half the American congress are millionaires. It’s mind boggling. How on earth can they have even the vaguest notion of what it’s like to live on not enough. Looking forward to reading your next post. I so admire your blogging energy!

  4. Since I live in the U.S. too, I can say that I’m alarmed to hear that in 2012, the rich are getting richer and the poor poorer. They said today that the gap is widening and I’m shocked.
    When you talk about France, most Republican candidates in the U.S. talk about the socialism in France and what you said about the politicians. proves that they are not socialists, but greedy, just like politicians all over the world.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *